Skip to main content

Bronze Age cheese reveals human and Lactobacillus kefiranofaciens interactions throughout evolutionary history

Bronze Age cheese reveals human and Lactobacillus kefiranofaciens interactions throughout evolutionary history

NEWS - Food fermentation using microorganisms is the oldest food processing practice in human history. Milk fermentation can be traced back to 6000–4000 BC in India and Mediterranean peoples produced and consumed cheese as early as 7000 BC.

However, little is known about the history of microbial use and the associated history of cultural transmission. In particular, the evolutionary trajectories, particularly the functional adaptations of these fermenting microorganisms through long-term interactions with humans, remain unclear.

Recently, Chinese researchers conducted the world’s first metagenomic study of Bronze Age kefir cheese excavated from the Xiaohe cemetery, the oldest dairy remains known to date. Molecular evidence from ancient fermented milk residues serves as a powerful tool for understanding fermentation-microbe interactions.

The researchers have now extracted high-quality genomes of Lactobacillus kefiranofaciens (Lactobacillus kefiranofaciens) from three ancient cheese samples excavated from the Xiaohe cemetery in Xinjiang from around 3,500 years ago. The key was designing probes to enrich Lactobacillus DNA, increasing the target DNA from less 1% to 64-80% and allowing the reconstruction of the entire genome.

“We have been working on this project for more than 11 years. This is an unprecedented study, allowing us to observe how bacteria have evolved over the past 3,000 years,” said Fu Qiaomei, Chinese Academy of Sciences.

“In addition, we have gained a clearer picture of the lives of ancient humans and their interactions with the world. This is just the beginning, and with this technology, we hope to explore other previously unknown artifacts,” Fu said.

The cheese sample excavated from the Xiaohe Cemetery in Xinjiang is the earliest cheese product ever discovered. It was previously identified through paleoproteomics as kefir cheese, a fermented milk product made using kefir grains, which contain fermenting microbes.

The study confirmed that the cheese was made using lactic acid bacteria and yeast. The researchers also found that the milk used to make the cheese came from a group of goats that were widespread in Eurasia during the post-Neolithic period, distinct from contemporary domesticated goats from the interior of East Asia.

These findings suggest that the ancient people of Tarim Basim may have learned kefir production techniques from Eurasian steppe populations. The spread of milk fermentation technology was largely accompanied by human migration and interaction, a process that drove the evolution of lactic acid bacteria.

However, this study also uncovered a new route of dispersal of L. kefiranofaciens by analyzing the phylogenetic relationships of ancient L. kefiranofaciens in Xinjiang. The researchers found that L. kefiranofaciens used in fermentation consisted of two clades.

The first clade mainly consisted of strains from Europe (e.g., modern Germany) and coastal and island regions of Asia (e.g., modern Guangdong, Taiwan Island, Japan, and Singapore). This distribution corresponds to a dispersal route from the Caucasus to Europe on the one hand and to coastal regions of Asia and Southeast Asia on the other. The other clade mainly consisted of strains distributed inland in East Asia (including Tibet).

The ancient strains are located at the base of the clade, suggesting an additional route of dispersal of kefir production technology from Xinjiang to inland East Asia through technological-cultural exchange. The divergence of the two clades is likely the result of the dispersal of the originally domesticated ancestor in different populations, reflecting migrations and interactions that occurred during the use and domestication of microorganisms.

“It is fascinating to see how much information can be extracted from this cheese. Organic residues provide a window into past human behavior and culture that is lost in history and records,” said Yang Yimin from the Chinese Academy of Sciences.

The study also found that human use and domestication played an important role in the evolution of L. kefiranofaciens. Comparative analysis of the genomes of L. kefiranofaciens from the Bronze Age and modern times allows us to characterize the adaptive evolution of L. kefiranofaciens over the past few thousand years.

Extensive horizontal gene transfer is one of the main mechanisms of adaptive evolution in lactic acid bacteria. By comparing the functional profiles of ancient and modern L. kefiranofaciens, the study identified three main evolutionary trajectories of L. kefiranofaciens.

Adaptation to environmental stress with the emergence of drug resistance-related genes in modern strains. Enhanced bacterial genomic defense mechanisms with modern L. kefiranofaciens showing gene clusters such as the R-M system and associated toxin-antitoxin systems that can counteract the entry of exogenous DNA and thereby reduce associated fitness costs.

Adaptations related to the human gut environment, for example, modern strains acquired gene clusters that potentially interact with the host gut, most likely due to long-term interactions with humans.

The study also found that long-term human use and domestication of L. kefiranofaciens likely also influenced evolution. Compared with Bronze Age L. kefiranofaciens, modern strains from Tibet showed two horizontally transferred gene clusters associated with reduced gut inflammatory responses.

Given that ancient populations could easily spread kefir production technology via kefir grains, the presence of these gene clusters is likely related to a preference among contemporaneous populations for kefir grains carrying distinct clades of L. kefiranofaciens.

By using ancient DNA information about fermenting microorganisms that are closely associated with past human activities and cultures, this study offers a new framework for using ancient DNA to study past human-cultural interactions.

Original research

Liu, Yichen et al. (2024). Bronze Age cheese reveals human-Lactobacillus interactions over evolutionary history. Cell, DOI:10.1016/j.cell.2024.08.008

Dlium theDlium
Labels:

Popular Posts

Sea almond (Terminalia catappa)

Ketapang or tropical almond or beach almond or talisay tree or umbrella tree or sea almond ( Terminalia catappa ) is a species of plant in the Combretaceae, a shady tree, fast growing, forming a multilevel canopy, often used as a shade tree in gardens and on roadsides. T. catappa grows large, up to 40 meters in height and up to 1.5 meters in trunk, shady canopy with branches that grow flat and terraced, young trees often look like pagodas while old and large trees often have aerial roots up to 3 meters. The leaves are scattered, mostly at the end of the twig, rounded egg upside down, 8-38 cm long, 5-19 cm wide, the tip is wide, the base is narrow, the upper surface is smooth, green but turns red if to fall out and short stalks. The flowers are small, collected near the tips of the twigs, 8-25 cm long and green-yellow in color. The flowers are not crowned, the petals have five taju, are plate or bell shaped, 4-8 mm long and are white or cream in color. Stamens in two circles and arra...
Read more

Asian foxtail (Uraria crinita)

Asian foxtail or cat's tail bean ( Uraria crinita ) is a species of plant in Fabaceae, a perennial, upright shrub with woody stems at least at the base, up to 2 meters high in forests, agricultural land, waterways, used as a medicinal herb, green manure and sometimes planted in the garden as an ornamental plant. U. crinita has elongated leaves, rounded base, pointed tip, a bone in the middle with several pinnate veins, rough surface, dark green with white spots. Petiole short or less than 0.5 cm and brownish red. Compound flower in spike shape, purple and white triangular crown. Long flower stalk, erect, 15-20 cm long and only at the end of the flower. The crown slowly falls off and leaves behind a stalk that is shaped like coir or light yellow pads. Asian foxtail grows in dry grasslands, open forests, trash cans, roadsides, sandy areas and sometimes in deciduous forests, elevations of 0-1500 meters and does not grow in waterlogged places. The different parts are often used in t...
Read more

Kunu buti (Mesosphaerum suaveolens)

Kunu buti ( Mesosphaerum suaveolens ) is a species of plant in the Lamiaceae family. It is an erect, herbaceous annual, growing up to 1.5 meters tall. Its cylindrical, rough, brown or green stem is hairy and white. It grows on forest floors, bushes, agricultural fields, and roadsides. Its roots are fibrous and brownish-yellow. M. suaveolens has single, opposite leaves, stalks 2-5 cm long and hairy. The leaf blades are green, hairy, oval, with pointed tips, blunt bases, serrated edges, up to 6 cm long, up to 5 cm wide, and pinnate veins. The flowers are compound, axillary, in clusters, perfect, and bisexual. The petals are attached, forming a tube, each tip elongated like a spine, soft, 3-10 mm long, and green. The corolla is attached, asymmetrically detached, 1-2 cm long, and purple. The fruit is single, hard, capsule-shaped, hairy on the surface, and green or brown in color. The seeds are round, small and blackish brown in color. TAXON Kingdom: Plantae Phylum: Tracheophyta Subphyl...
Read more